When is a director personally liable towards creditors?
As a director of a B.V., you are generally protected by the corporate veil, which separates your personal assets from the company's liabilities. However, this shield is not absolute. Under Dutch law, a creditor may hold you personally liable if your actions constitute an unlawful act or tort, as defined under section 6:162 of the Dutch Civil Code (DCC).
This form of liability is distinct from liability to the company itself, as it involves a claim by a third party. For a court to find you personally liable, you must have committed a serious professional error that goes beyond a standard business mistake. The threshold is high, requiring proof that no reasonable director would have acted in the same manner.
The Beklamel standard: entering obligations you cannot meet
One of the most common grounds for personal liability is based on the Beklamel standard. This applies when you, as a director, enter into a contract or obligation on behalf of the company while knowing—or having every reason to know—that the company will be unable to pay the debt.
To succeed with such a claim, a creditor must prove you knew that the company would neither pay the agreed amount nor offer any recourse for the shortfall. It is not enough that the company is simply facing a temporary cash flow issue. You must have essentially committed the company to an obligation it had no realistic prospect of ever fulfilling.
Frustrating payment and recourse (Ontvanger/Roelofsen)
Beyond the inception of debt, liability can arise if you actively obstruct a creditor's ability to recover their money. This category, established in the Ontvanger/Roelofsen ECLI:NL:HR:2006:AZ0758 ruling, covers scenarios where you intentionally hinder a creditor’s recourse.
This might involve selective payment of other creditors, stripping the company of assets, or failing to take obvious steps to improve the financial situation, such as collecting outstanding invoices. If your actions leave a creditor empty-handed while others are prioritised without a legitimate business justification, you risk being held personally accountable. This concept often overlaps with issues involving directors’ personal liability after a turbo liquidation.
Red figures and the boundary of responsible enterprise
It is vital to understand that simply operating a company with negative equity is not, in itself, a tort. Every entrepreneur takes risks, and some degree of financial difficulty is a common aspect of business life. Liability only kicks in when you cross the boundary of what is considered responsible enterprise.
This boundary is breached when you continue to trade while knowing that the company's situation is essentially hopeless, or when you continue to incur new debts without a viable recovery plan. You are expected to act prudently; once it becomes clear that your company is failing and cannot satisfy its obligations, you must stop incurring further liabilities or prepare for an orderly wind-down.
The director who is itself a company (s. 2:11 DCC)
In many structures, the management of a B.V. is not held by a natural person, but by another legal entity, often a holding company. Section 2:11 of the DCC exists to prevent directors from hiding behind this corporate structure to escape personal liability.
This section allows the court to 'pierce the corporate veil' and hold the directors of that managing holding company personally liable. Consequently, if your holding company acts as the director of your operational B.V., you as the individual behind that holding entity can still be held liable for the management of the subsidiary. It ensures that the responsibility for improper management remains with the actual human decision-makers.
Key points at a glance
- The corporate veil protects your assets, but personal liability arises if you act with serious recklessness or intent.
- Do not enter into new contracts if you know the company cannot pay and will not be able to provide recourse.
- Avoid selective payments that unfairly disadvantage specific creditors over others.
- Ensure accurate financial administration so you can prove the rationale behind your management decisions.
- Be aware that being a holding company does not insulate you from personal liability under section 2:11 DCC.
- Seek timely legal advice when your company faces severe financial distress or structural losses.
- Liability is not about making a wrong business guess, but about failing to meet the basic standards of responsible conduct.
What should you do now?
Managing the risks of external directors’ liability requires a proactive approach and a clear understanding of your fiduciary duties. If your company is entering a period of significant financial instability, or if you receive a claim from a creditor threatening personal liability, do not wait for the situation to escalate. Engaging a corporate law lawyer at an early stage is essential to assess your risks, document your decision-making process, and develop a strategy to protect both the company and your personal position. Contact our office today for professional guidance tailored to your specific situation.
Questions about directors' liability?
Mr. Vincent Besters is happy to help. Contact us for a no-obligation first consultation.
Get in touch →
Do you have legal questions following this ruling?
Mr. Vincent Besters is happy to help. Contact us for a no-obligation first consultation.
Get in touch →